A plate of fresh North Atlantic fish served in an Icelandic restaurant

Table

A Culinary Journey Through Iceland

PLACE

Iceland

READ

7 min

INDEX

02

0 %

Lamb from the highlands, fish from the North Atlantic and bread baked in hot ground. What to eat in Iceland, and where to eat it.

An Icelandic hot dog with crispy onions, mustard and remoulade

‘Eina með öllu’: one with everything

Ask an Icelander about the food of their childhood and you will hear about lamb soup on a cold Sunday, rye bread so dark it is almost black, and a grandmother who would not let a fish go to waste. For most of its history this was a hungry island at the edge of the Arctic, and the cuisine grew out of what the land and the sea could give and what could be preserved through a long winter. Today that frugal tradition sits alongside one of the most exciting small food scenes in Europe.

This is our guide to eating well in Iceland, from the dishes every visitor should try to the places our hosts actually go.

The three pillars of Icelandic cuisine

Lamb

Icelandic sheep descend from the animals the Norse settlers brought over more than a thousand years ago. Every summer they roam freely across mountains and highland pastures, grazing on grasses, sedges and wild herbs such as thyme and angelica. In September, farmers and neighbours ride out together to bring them home in a round-up called réttir, one of the great social events of the rural year. The meat is tender and gently flavoured, quite unlike intensively farmed lamb.

Seafood from the North Atlantic

Fishing built modern Iceland. The cold, nutrient-rich waters where the Gulf Stream meets Arctic currents produce cod and haddock of remarkable quality, along with Arctic char, salmon, herring and langoustine. In Iceland, fish is not a luxury. It is the everyday meal, and it is usually landed only hours before it reaches your plate.

Dairy, and above all skyr

Skyr arrived with the settlers and has been made here for over a thousand years. It is thick, mild and high in protein, and technically a soft cheese made with skimmed milk rather than a yogurt. Icelanders eat it for breakfast and dessert, traditionally with a splash of cream and fresh berries. Icelandic butter, from grass-fed cows, deserves its own mention. Try it on warm bread and you will understand.

Free-roaming Icelandic sheep grazing in highland pasture in late summer

Traditional Icelandic dishes you should try

Kjötsúpa: lamb soup

If one dish tastes like an Icelandic home, it is kjötsúpa. Lamb on the bone simmers slowly with potatoes, swede, carrots, onion and a handful of rice or oats until everything is tender. It is the meal for a winter evening after a day in the wind, and every family has its own version.

Plokkfiskur: fish stew

Plokkfiskur means something like ‘picked fish’. Boiled cod or haddock is flaked into a white sauce with potatoes and onion, seasoned with plenty of pepper and often served with buttered rye bread. It started as a way to use leftovers and became one of the country’s great comfort foods.

Hangikjöt on flatkaka

Hangikjöt, ‘hung meat’, is lamb smoked slowly, traditionally over dried sheep dung or birch. It is a centrepiece of Christmas, served hot with potatoes in white sauce and green peas, but it is just as good cold and thinly sliced on flatkaka, a soft rye flatbread charred on a hot griddle, with butter.

Rúgbrauð: rye bread baked in the ground

Rúgbrauð is a dense, dark, slightly sweet rye bread. Traditionally the dough was sealed in a pot and buried in hot geothermal ground for around 24 hours, and the steady underground heat caramelises the sugars. At Laugarvatn Fontana, beside the lake of the same name, bakers still dig the bread out of the steaming black sand for visitors. Eat it warm with butter and smoked trout or pickled herring.

Sliced dark Icelandic rye bread on a wooden board

Pylsur: the Icelandic hot dog

Do not leave without one. Icelandic hot dogs are made mostly from lamb, with pork and beef, which gives them a distinctive flavour and a snap. Order one ‘eina með öllu’, one with everything: raw onions, crispy fried onions, ketchup, the sweet brown mustard called pylsusinnep, and remoulade. Bæjarins Beztu Pylsur, a small stand near the harbour in Reykjavík, has been serving them since 1937, and the queue is part of the experience.

Hákarl and brennivín

Hákarl is fermented Greenland shark. The fresh meat is toxic, so it is cured for weeks and then hung to dry for several months, a technique that let earlier generations turn a dangerous fish into valuable food. The smell is strong and the taste is, let’s say, memorable. Locals take a small cube with a shot of brennivín, a caraway-flavoured schnapps nicknamed ‘Black Death’. At Bjarnarhöfn on the Snæfellsnes peninsula, one family has prepared hákarl for generations and will show you how it is done.

Þorramatur: the midwinter feast

In the old Norse calendar, the month of Þorri begins in late January and runs into late February. It was the hardest stretch of winter, and today it is marked by Þorrablót feasts where families, workplaces and villages gather to eat þorramatur, the traditional preserved foods. Expect hákarl, svið (singed sheep’s head), súrsaðir hrútspungar (ram’s testicles soured in whey), blood and liver sausages, dried fish and rye bread, washed down with brennivín. It is as much about community and humour as food, and if you are invited to one, say yes.

Kleinur, snúður and skúffukaka

Icelanders take their coffee breaks seriously, and the bakery, bakarí, is a national institution. Look for kleinur, twisted doughnuts fried in fat and flavoured with cardamom; snúður, a big cinnamon roll topped with chocolate or caramel glaze; and skúffukaka, a soft chocolate sheet cake with chocolate icing and a scattering of coconut.

Where to eat in Iceland

Fine dining

Reykjavík is small, but it has a serious fine dining scene. Dill, on Laugavegur, became the first Icelandic restaurant to earn a Michelin star and holds one today, with a tasting menu built on Icelandic ingredients and a strong sustainability ethos. ÓX, an intimate chef’s counter, also holds a star, and several other Reykjavík restaurants, including Matur og Drykkur with its playful take on old Icelandic recipes, are recommended by the guide. For a country of around 395,000 people, that is a remarkable concentration of talent. Book well ahead.

Authentic local cooking

Þrír Frakkar, a cosy restaurant in a residential corner of central Reykjavík, has served traditional fish dishes since 1989 and is where many locals take visiting family. On the Snæfellsnes peninsula, Hótel Búðir stands alone on a lava field by the sea, and its restaurant is a lovely place to eat fish and lamb while watching the light change over Snæfellsjökull.

Casual food and food halls

Reykjavík’s food halls, called mathallir, are the easiest way to eat well and affordably. Hlemmur Mathöll, the city’s first, opened in 2017 in an old bus terminal at the top of Laugavegur. Pósthús Mathöll in the old post office and Grandi Mathöll in a former fish shed by the harbour are just as good. Around the Old Harbour you will also find simple seafood shacks serving fish and chips and lobster soup.

Beyond Reykjavík

Some of the best meals in Iceland happen far from the capital. Friðheimar, a geothermal greenhouse in Reykholt on the Golden Circle, serves fresh tomato soup among the tomato vines. Höfn, in the southeast, is known for langoustine. In the Westfjords, small family cafés serve fish caught that morning, and in the north, farms such as those around Lake Mývatn sell smoked trout and lamb. Along the Ring Road, countryside guesthouses often cook a set dinner with whatever is best that day. These are the places our hosts love most.

Tomato plants growing in a geothermally heated greenhouse in Iceland

Eating well on a budget

There is no point pretending otherwise: eating out in Iceland is expensive. But with a little planning you can eat very well without spending a fortune.

  • Shop at Bónus or Krónan, the two main budget supermarkets, and cook at your accommodation for some of your meals.

  • Eat your big meal at lunch. Many restaurants offer a lunch special, hádegistilboð, that costs far less than the same food at dinner.

  • Embrace the hot dog and the bakery. A pylsa and a cinnamon roll make a cheap and very Icelandic lunch.

  • Drink the tap water. Icelandic tap water is some of the cleanest in the world, so never buy bottled. The hot tap may smell faintly of sulphur because it is geothermal, but the cold tap is fresh and delicious.

  • Save alcohol for special moments. It is heavily taxed and sold only in state-run Vínbúðin shops, so look for happy hours in bars.

  • Don’t worry about tipping. Service is included in prices, and tipping is not expected.

Iceland’s culinary renaissance

Twenty-five years ago, Icelandic food had a reputation for fermented shark and little else. That changed fast. The Food & Fun festival, first held in Reykjavík in 2002, began pairing visiting chefs from around the world with local kitchens every late winter. Around the same time, the New Nordic food movement, set out in a 2004 manifesto by Scandinavian chefs, gave Icelandic cooks a language for what they already knew: that the best food here is hyper-local, seasonal and honest.

Today young chefs forage for angelica, sea herbs and wild berries, work directly with farmers and fishers, and revive old preservation techniques with new precision. Geothermal greenhouses grow vegetables year-round, and small producers make cheese, beer and gin with real character. The roots are old, but the cooking feels new.

Taste Iceland with the people who grew up on it

The quickest way into a culture is through its kitchen. Our culinary hosts are chefs, farmers and home cooks who will feed you the food they grew up with: lamb soup in a farmhouse kitchen, fish straight from the harbour, rye bread pulled from the hot earth, and the stories that go with them. If you are planning your days around the table, pair them with evenings chasing the aurora and a soak in hot water, and read our tips for first-time visitors before you go.

Aurora & Locals — Taste the Real Iceland

In Iceland, fish is not a luxury. It is the everyday meal, landed hours before it reaches your plate.

Fresh North Atlantic cod fillets

North Atlantic cod, usually landed only hours earlier

Green Northern Lights over snowy mountains reflected in still water in Iceland

01

Aurora

The Ultimate Aurora Hunting Guide to Iceland

8 min

Iceland

A plate of fresh North Atlantic fish served in an Icelandic restaurant

02

Table

A Culinary Journey Through Iceland

7 min

Iceland

Steam rising over milky-blue geothermal water and moss-covered lava in Iceland

03

Hot Water

Rejuvenate in the Land of Fire and Ice

8 min

Iceland